Looking to upgrade my everyday makeup look

I learned how to do 5 minute natural makeup when I was 14 and my makeup look hasn’t evolved much despite it being years later. I’d love a more mature look that will flatter my features. My current products are as follows:

Mac Concealer palette under eyes Clear brow gel (my brows are curly so I could use something with more hold) Black Mascara by Tower 28 Honest Beauty Orange Cream Blush Maede Beauty lip balm