Is there such a thing as too OP?

We see a lot of posts about an OP protagonist, and it seems to be something people really enjoy reading, especially if there are some satisfying moments with the MC awing people with their power.

On the other hand, having a too strong MC is rarely a point of criticism. Is that because stories with that problem rarely ever catch the eye of the community?

I would love to have someone who is already strong getting system'd or isekai'd, but in that case the story would need to focus on problems you couldn't just solve with strength or go into a different direction, like slice of life.

Perhaps I just haven't read enough stories or missed it, but I would love to hear your thoughts and recommendations :]