CDN Iconic nothing like BdC

I am wondering if I got a bad batch of iconic. I ordered off the Amazon store for Armaf so I didn’t buy secondhand or anything.

To my nose, they smell almost nothing alike. I tested with my wife too side by side and she didn’t even realize one was supposed to be a clone.

Iconic smells a lot harsher, almost like a cross between green Irish tweed and blue de Chanel.

I have quite a few other Armaf colognes and I think they really do a great job and are a lot closer. For example, I tried green Irish Tweed with Tren nuit and I feel like it’s very similar.

Did I get a bad batch or are they just not that close like I would say the similarity would be about 60%.