Any more “classic” stories?
At this point they’ve read and covered a lot of the older “classic” creepypastas, ranging from both the cheesy icon stories (Jeff the killer, eyeless Jack, etc) to the well-written classics (penpal, Ted the caver, etc).
Are there many more stories that would still fall under that “classic creepypasta” category from back when the genre was super popular that they haven’t read yet? Don’t get me wrong I love them reading newer stuff (and would be over the moon if my stuff got read eventually). However, I think it’s pretty apparent that they try to hold back on their criticism of the story if they’re reading something new as not to hurt the author’s feelings. The episodes where they read something older are generally a lot of fun because the story has to either be really good or really bad to still be notable enough to cover.
What do you guys think? Personally I’m still waiting on the last few parts of Borrasca, the ending was really good from what I remember.
Edit Sunday 3/9/25: No way to confirm this but looks like they might’ve seen this post lol