Who is a contestant that was loved during their season but you could never get into

So I’ll admit I haven’t watched idol since the second ABC season but I still like to discuss the show from its golden days because those were really fun times for me so I’m curious who could you really not get into but yet everyone else loved. For me it was Phillip Phillips I never thought he sounded good and all his performances sounded the same I thought Jessica Sanchez should have won that season who are your picks