American Idol Winners at War

It literally makes no sense to do a season like this but who could win an all winners season in a hypothetical season?

  • Kelly Clarkson

  • Ruben Studdard

  • Fantasia

  • Carrie Underwood

  • Taylor Hicks

  • Jordin Sparks

  • David Cook

  • Kris Allen

  • Lee DeWyze

  • Scotty McCreery

  • Phillip Phillips

  • Candice Glover

  • Caleb Johnson

  • Nick Fradiani

  • Trent Harmon

  • Maddie Poppe

  • Laine Hardy

  • Just Sam

  • Chayce Beckham

  • Noah Thompson

  • Iam Tongi

  • Abi Carter