American Idol Winners at War

It literally makes no sense to do a season like this but who could win an all winners season in a hypothetical season?

• Kelly Clarkson

• Ruben Studdard

• Fantasia

• Carrie Underwood

• Taylor Hicks

• Jordin Sparks

• David Cook

• Kris Allen

• Lee DeWyze

• Scotty McCreery

• Phillip Phillips

• Candice Glover

• Caleb Johnson

• Nick Fradiani

• Trent Harmon

• Maddie Poppe

• Laine Hardy

• Just Sam

• Chayce Beckham

• Noah Thompson

• Iam Tongi

• Abi Carter