I have sensitive skin

Hi, I generally have decent skin with little to no problems but lately. My skin has become very itchy after using the Ponds Dry Skin Cream. Like it’s literally makes my skin feel like it’s on fire. I’ve used it for a couple months now and I haven’t had a problem until now. So, I tried using non-fragrance oatmeal lotion and that made my skin feel the same way. I had to immediately wash my face. I used petroleum jelly and it calmed my skin down instantly and I had no itchy, burning feeling.

Can you recommend some moisturizers that are good for sensitive skin? Please and thank you.