Which Persona game do you believe received the best live action adaptation?
I personally believe P3W easily had the best overall stage and costume design, and the best songs. The cast is really great too. Having the story told via either Makoto or Kotone depending on the evening you viewed it is really clever, too.
However, while not technically the best imo, my personal favourite out of the four has to be Persona 5's adaptation. I think the cast here absolutely killed it. Hiroki Ino is THE live action Joker to me, and the rest of the Phantom Thieves are absolutely great too. Unfortunately I don't think the set design is nearly as good as it was for P3W, and some of the singing performances aren't the best.
I think P4V relied way too heavily on the slightly awkward projection effects. I can totally see what they were going for, and in some instances it really works, but most of the time it doesn't.
I personally believe P3W easily had the best overall stage and costume design, and the best songs. The cast is really great too. Having the story told via either Makoto or Kotone depending on the evening you viewed it is really clever, too.
However, while not technically the best imo, my personal favourite out of the four has to be Persona 5's adaptation. I think the cast here absolutely killed it. Hiroki Ino is THE live action Joker to me, and the rest of the Phantom Thieves are absolutely great too. Unfortunately I don't think the set design is nearly as good as it was for P3W, and some of the singing performances aren't the best.
I think P4V relied way too heavily on the slightly awkward projection effects. I can totally see what they were going for, and in some instances it really works, but most of the time it doesn't.