Possibility of getting from All Nighter to a show on 45th such as Dorian Gray or John Proctor in time?

Thinking of seeing All Nighter on a Friday at 5pm. With a runtime of 1 hour and 35 minutes, how possible do you think it is to get from All Nighter (Newman Mills Theater at MCC) to a show on 45th street (Dorian Gray, John Proctor) with a 7pm start time? I don’t want to miss anything and I would walk fast. Just trying to gather opinions on this.